The UK RAAC Campaign Group has received a detailed response from Scotland’s new Cabinet Secretary for Housing, Màiri McAllan MSP, to our calls for legislative reform, Homebuyer Report improvements, and direct engagement with all affected residents. One of the most welcome developments is her agreement to put our legislative suggestions to the UK Government and to raise our Homebuyer Report reform proposals with the Scottish Government’s Building Standards Team. We will also expect that any responses from the UK Government and from Building Standards are forwarded to us, so affected homeowners can see clear lines of accountability and progress.
Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman of the UK RAAC Capaign Group, said: “We welcome the Cabinet Secretary’s commitment to raise our proposals at both UK and Scottish levels — but what matters now is that homeowners see transparent responses and real progress, not just promises.”
What those legislative changes could look like (from our submission)
Our submission urges Westminster to:
-
Amend key UK legislation — including the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, Finance Act 2003, and Insurance Act 2015 — to provide fairer financial relief (0% interest charges on outstanding mortgages), improved insurance access, and property purchasing support (such as restoring First Home Buyer status) for homeowners affected by RAAC or anyother safety defect through no fault of their own.
-
Introduce new product safety legislation for housing, modelled on the General Product Safety Regulations, to hold developers and contractors accountable for long-term safety defects — including RAAC and unsafe cladding.
-
Mandate enhanced home-buying surveys that assess building materials and long-term structural risks, to prevent similar housing crises in future.
-
Create a UK-wide compensation or rebuilding fund for RAAC-affected homes — ideally with Scottish Government co-funding and policy leadership — to support those unable to access insurance or meaningful compensation locally.
UK Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Democracy and Local Growth, Minister Alex Norris has said he considers many of these issues to be devolved matters, which is why we have now asked the Scottish Government to raise them formally with Westminster through the appropriate intergovernmental forums.
Wilson Chowdhry, added:
"These reforms are not radical — they are common-sense protections to ensure families are never left abandoned in unsafe homes again. We are calling for UK and Scottish Governments to work together, because affected homeowners don’t care which level of government acts first; they just need urgent, joined-up solutions."
Positive Outcomes from the Minister’s Response
1) Recognition of the crisis and a commitment to collaboration (but this alone isn’t new)
The Scottish Government has acknowledged the distress facing RAAC homeowners for some time. What matters now is delivery: the letter reiterates an intention to bring parties together for “solutions and agreed pathways to resolution.” We agree on shared accountability between the UK and Scottish Governments—and we’ve set out that if Westminster keeps refusing funding, Holyrood must act unilaterally. With affordable options like ReGrid on the table, neither government can plead cost as a barrier.
2) Commitment to push the UK Government on funding
The Minister again states that the UK Government bears responsibility for homes sold pre-devolution under Right to Buy and that she will keep pressing for a UK-wide remediation fund. That aligns with our stance on shared accountability—but we’ve been clear that Scotland must not simply keep chasing Westminster if it refuses. A Scottish-led programme remains essential if UK action stalls.
3) A more inclusive approach to resident engagement
We welcome the plan to meet all residents in affected areas, not just a select few who’ve had media attention. Homeowners face widely differing personal, financial and structural problems; every voice deserves to be heard. This is especially important given that early meetings arranged by certain local SNP MSPs were politically filtered, with only their supporters invited—something we challenged from day one. People have been harmed by this situation; they deserve the right to address senior decision-makers directly and without gatekeeping. The Minister’s letter confirms meetings in areas with the highest numbers of privately owned RAAC-affected properties, with residents, local campaign groups and elected representatives invited.
4) A national RAAC in Housing Response Group
The Scottish Government will convene a RAAC in Housing Response Group—bringing together Chief Executives of affected councils and RSLs alongside other key actors—to drive pace and progress. Done well, this can coordinate a national strategy and unblock delays.
5) Practical technical guidance
The Government is supporting the Institution of Structural Engineers to publish RAAC-specific housing guidance later this summer, covering assessment and template solutions—useful groundwork if it’s paired with funding and delivery.
6) A separate meeting with UK RAAC Campaign Group leadership
The Minister has agreed a dedicated meeting with the UKRAAC Campaign Group as part of her wider engagement. We see this as clear recognition of our leadership: the leading petitions have been authored by us; we’ve submitted evidence to the Scottish Parliament’s Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee on Building Safety; and contributed to the UK Government’s Green Paper on Construction Products. Evidence we supplied to Alex Norris MP (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Building Safety, Fire and Local Growth) has been passed to the Building Safety Regulator (BSR) as they continue to monitor RAAC under the Building Safety Act 2022.
Fiona Crichton, Secretary for the UK RAAC Campaign Group, said:
"It’s encouraging to see the Scottish Government acknowledge the scale of the RAAC crisis and commit to action. But for homeowners, what matters most is delivery—real funding, practical solutions, and a coordinated strategy that doesn’t leave families waiting while governments debate responsibility."
Our Further Requests to the Minister
-
Forward all responses: We have asked the Housing Minister to share with us any responses received from the UK Government and from the Building Standards Team regarding our legislative proposals and Homebuyer Report reforms, so homeowners can see progress in real time.
-
Public Inquiry: We continue to call for a full public inquiry to establish responsibility across local, Scottish and UK levels, given decades of missed warnings and policy failures.
-
Tailored solutions for Scotland’s uniquely severe crisis: With over 1,300 private homeowners affected—far more than anywhere else in the UK—Scotland needs bespoke solutions proportionate to the scale of the problem.
-
Practical, affordable remediation pathways: Evaluate non-intrusive options such as ReGrid—a carbon-fibre/Kevlar® reinforcement tested on critical infrastructure, installable in ~2 days without relocations, at a fraction of full replacement cost. This could make a national programme financially viable.
-
Firm meeting dates with inclusive invites: Confirm dates for Clackmannanshire and West Lothian, Dundee and Aberdeen homeowner meetings, ensuring all residents, local groups and elected representatives are invited—not a hand-picked few. Other Groups will be added to this list.
-
First Minister attendance for solutions-focused talks: We have formally requested First Minister John Swinney to attend our meeting with the Housing Minister. This is not just another opportunity to describe the impact on homeowners—which Ministers must be acutely aware of by now—but a session to discuss practical solutions, a public inquiry, funding mechanisms and timelines. The First Minister’s presence is vital because only he has the authority to commit the Scottish Government to concrete actions, ensure cross-departmental coordination, and escalate matters to Westminster where UK-wide intervention is required. His attendance will be a clear test of leadership and accountability: whether the Scottish Government is willing to take responsibility for securing urgent, workable solutions for families whose lives remain in limbo.
"Homeowners need action, not just words. The First Minister’s attendance is critical—it signals real accountability and gives hope that practical solutions, proper funding, and tailored support will finally reach those living in unsafe homes across Scotland."
Looking Ahead
There are now explicit commitments to take our legislative and Homebuyer Report proposals forward, to involve all affected residents in future meetings, to convene a national RAAC Response Group, and to meet UKRCG leadership separately in recognition of our role and evidence base. We will continue to hold both governments to account—and we expect timely forwarding of any UK Government and Building Standards replies—so every homeowner, regardless of political connections or media profile, has a path to safety and resolution.