Wednesday 6 November 2024

Emotional Re-Entry for RAAC-Evacuated Tillicoultry Homeowners as Clackmannanshire Council Coordinates Valuable Item Retrieval

An AMC removal van parked outside the evacuated Tillicoultry flats, ready to assist with the removal of residents' belongings.

PLEASE JOIN OUR 'UK RAAC CAMPAIGN GROUP' FB PAGE (HERE)

PLEASE SIGN OUR PETITIONS FOR UK GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE) and OFFICIAL SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE)

WATCH FIRST NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL NEWS FEATURE ON RAAC HOUSING CRISES (HERE)

Tillicoultry, Clackmannanshire, 6th November 2024 – After over one year of displacement and logistical setbacks, RAAC-affected homeowners in Tillicoultry are finally being granted one final access to their homes to retrieve essential belongings. This emotional milestone, coordinated by Clackmannanshire Council with support from Kevin Wells and Wilson Lees, follows a prolonged struggle to address the practical and psychological toll of displacement for the affected families.

The road to this re-entry process has been a complex one. Initially, homeowners had been in frequent communication with Wilson Lees, the Homelessness and Supporting People Manager, who maintained regular contact with residents over WhatsApp for a year. “Wilson was our primary connection with the council when things were at their most confusing,” said one homeowner. “His support helped us feel like someone in the council understood what we were going through.”

A liveried Clackmannanshire Council van was utilized by officers to assist with the re-entry process.

In the early stages, Wilson Lees had suggested that accompanied re-entries might be feasible. However, when a scheduled meeting on 22nd September was unexpectedly cancelled by Strategic Director of Place, Kevin Wells, homeowners were left in limbo. The sudden termination of the dedicated WhatsApp group—a crucial communication lifeline—added to the confusion, leaving many feeling abandoned by the council.

This cancellation was a major setback for families who had taken time off work, carefully prepared questions, and expected to receive structured logistical plans for re-entry along with details on overall support. “We’d rearranged our lives and cleared our schedules, hoping to get concrete answers,” said one resident. “But with the meeting suddenly off the table, it felt like we were back at square one.”

Jim Vallance pictured with Denise Hamilton, the mother of a homeowner, as they support each other while retrieving belongings on the same day.

Wilson Chowdhry Pushes for Rescheduled Access

In response, Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, pressed the council to reschedule the meeting and expedite decisions for re-entry, stressing the mounting emotional strain on homeowners. “People were desperate to collect their things and wanted a clearer understanding at where things were heading so tey could  begin rebuilding some normalcy, but these cancellations and delays made the situation feel endless,” Chowdhry said. He emphasized the urgent need to confirm the feasibility of re-entries, especially for residents still facing mortgage, rent, and utility payments on vacated properties.

After weeks of communication and advocacy, a rescheduled meeting finally took place on 20th October, where Chowdhry, and Wells, discussed logistics for the item retrieval process. The meeting, though positive, was a disappointment for residents as the council underscored the safety challenges of accessing the RAAC-affected buildings. It was ultimately decided that residents would need to view their belongings remotely, through a video link to avoid structural risks. Although residents had hoped for more direct access, they agreed, recognizing there was no other option open to them. However, they requested larger viewing screens for ease – a request that was unfortunately met with only a mobile phone link due to logistical constraints.

An AMC Removal van, prepared and ready for packing and loading.

Challenging Scheduling for Re-Entry

Scheduling re-entry dates also proved challenging, with families trying to coordinate around work and personal commitments. Homeowners like Lynsey Maquater faced particular difficulties; her original re-entry was planned for 5th November, but personal obligations required a new date, which the council was able to adjust to 31st October. These logistical hurdles added strain to what was already an emotionally charged process.

The re-entry schedule unfolded as follows:

  • 30th October – 81 Chapelle Crescent
  • 31st October – High Street and Park Street Residents (excluding resident of 39 High Street)
  • 6th & 7th November – Resident of 39 High Street, given the extensive material requiring clearance.
Jim and Fiona squinted intently at the small phone screen, trying to make out details of their flat during the video link viewing.

Process and Challenges: The re-entry process, coordinated by Clackmannanshire Council and AMC Removals, required careful planning due to structural safety concerns. Residents were not permitted to physically enter the properties themselves; instead, they viewed the removal of items via a video link in a protective cabin. Although a larger screen was requested, residents had to make do with a mobile phone view, which further complicated an already challenging experience.

The council’s chosen contractor, AMC Removals, coordinated a detailed removal process involving multiple vehicles, staff, and council officials. Homeowners, though unable to enter their properties directly, viewed the retrieval of items from a protective cabin, monitoring the process via video feed. For some residents, the experience brought both relief and sorrow. There were also two council officers who were praised for their sensitivity and support, easing the difficult process for residents. “The staff were incredibly patient and flexible, which really helped reduce the anxiety everyone was feeling,” said Hamilton.

Jim signing an authority and liability waiver to allow the removal of his belongings to proceed.

Emotional Experiences During the Re-Entry Process:

  • Denise Hamilton described a poignant moment as she sat in a small mobile cabin outside her former home. “I was okay until I sat down in the little hut and got a wee bit emotional speaking to [council officer] Kim about the situation everybody is in,” she shared. Hamilton was able to retrieve several items for her daughter Emma, including two wall heaters and a wall-mounted hall table. While grateful to see the property “in pretty good condition,” Hamilton added, “It’s just a little step forward, and there’s still a long way to go.”

  • Gary Morrison struggled with the state of his property on the top floor, which had accumulated significant damage due to inspections. “There was significant damage and debris... we couldn’t take the fridge/freezer due to mould, fungus, and insects,” Morrison noted. Although his refrigerator was beyond saving, Morrison appreciated the council’s efforts: “Kim was considerate and helpful, and the contractors did all the heavy lifting to move the washing machine to my garage. On the day, the staff could not have been better.”

  • Fiona Vallance and her husband, Jimmy, felt both relief and sorrow upon re-entering their property. “We felt a bit emotional seeing inside the flat,” she said. “The council and contractors were very kind and considerate. Kim was lovely, caring, and respectful while listening to us. We managed to get our radiators out, which we were pleased about.” However, the sight of the extensive damage, particularly holes in the ceiling, cast a shadow on the day. “We hope this will be finalised soon and let us continue with a normal life.”

  • Frances Reid echoed similar sentiments, feeling surprised and thankful for the condition of her items. “Guys, can I just say I was pleasantly surprised with the condition of the items after being boarded up all this time,” she said. “I got my leather sofa, beds, and mattresses into a van. I told them not to lift them if they were mouldy or damp, and they were okay. It was emotional – yes, sad – absolutely, but unfortunately, it’s another step we have to take.” Reid also extended her support to fellow homeowners, adding, “I’m here for anyone that needs me.”

  • Fiona Crichton was disappointed by the condition of some of her items. “I picked up the washer/dryer from Park St today and drove it to Edinburgh, but it doesn’t work. So it was a complete waste of time,” she shared. The sight of her flat’s condition was distressing, with furniture “thrown to the side by the workmen to get into the roof.” She added, “My flat is on the top floor, and seeing it in that state was difficult.”

  • Lynsey Maquater faced her own challenges during the process, struggling with logistics to retrieve her belongings. Although the council accommodated her need for a different entry date, a deeply personal item, a watch that once belonged to her father, could not be found. While there were no allegations of theft, the situation was upsetting for her and highlighted the emotional weight of the experience.


Looking Forward: Wilson Chowdhry Calls for Continued Support and Transparency from Clackmannanshire Council

Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, stressed the importance of sustained support and transparency from Clackmannanshire Council as the RAAC crisis continues to affect homeowners. “While the re-entry process has provided some much-needed relief, it is crucial that the council remains proactive in addressing the broader concerns these families face,” Chowdhry stated. “The ongoing impact of RAAC on these residents cannot be overstated. The emotional and financial strain they’ve endured, coupled with the uncertainty surrounding the future of their properties, means that immediate action is necessary. We continue to urge the council to expedite fair property valuations and offer compensation to ease the significant burdens on displaced homeowners.”

Chowdhry further emphasized that these families, who have faced an abrupt and often disheartening process, are now pushing for the council to be accountable and transparent in their future decisions. “It's vital that homeowners can trust the process moving forward and know that their concerns are being addressed swiftly and fairly,” he added.

In response to the ongoing challenges, homeowners have announced a protest on 8th November, from 11am to 12pm outside Kilncraigs, Greenside Street, Alloa, FK10 1EB, ahead of a scheduled meeting with Kevin Wells, Strategic Director of Place, set to begin at 12pm. Homeowners are inviting others to join them in standing up for the fair treatment and support they desperately need.

Furthermore, homeowners are planning another protest on 13th November, from 9:30am to 10:30am outside the Scottish Parliament, to coincide with the consideration of a petition being heard by the Scottish Parliament Petitions Committee. The petition calls for a national budget to assist RAAC homeowners, a public inquiry into the handling of the RAAC situation by councils, and legislative changes to prevent similar crises in the future. The UK RAAC petition is scheduled to be discussed around 10:50am, and homeowners are inviting all supporters to attend and show their solidarity.

“The fight is far from over,” Chowdhry concluded. “This is about securing the future of these homeowners and ensuring that no one else has to go through what they have. We need everyone’s voice in this movement to ensure that justice is served, and these families are treated with the fairness and respect they deserve.”

Friday 1 November 2024

Edward Mountain MSP Backs RAAC Homeowners’ Petition as Campaigners Push for £3.4bn Fund Allocation Ahead of Scottish Parliament Consideration and Protest on 13th November

IMAGE: Protestors from the UK RAAC Campaign Group were joined by Sir Edward Mountain MSP, who advocated for them by writing to Scottish Housing Minister Paul McLelland.

PLEASE JOIN OUR 'UK RAAC CAMPAIGN GROUP' FB PAGE (HERE)

PLEASE SIGN OUR PETITIONS FOR UK GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE) and OFFICIAL SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE)

WATCH FIRST NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL NEWS FEATURE ON RAAC HOUSING CRISES (HERE)

Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, alongside his daughter Hannah, has registered an online petition on the Scottish Parliament petition portal, which will be considered by the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee during its meeting on 13 November 2024 at HolyroodThe approximate time for the consideration will be 10.50am.

Members of the public can watch the meeting live via Parliament TV or attend in person by booking tickets through the Parliament's website, available one week prior to the meeting.

On 22 August, a response to the petition was submitted by the Building Standards Division of the Scottish Government, detailing current actions regarding Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (RAAC) affected properties. This response highlights that the Scottish Housing Regulator is actively working with registered social landlords (RSLs) to manage approximately 1,994 homes affected by RAAC. While the UK Government has not allocated national funding for RAAC repairs, local authorities are encouraged to support residents through their Scheme of Assistance Strategies. The government does not see a need for a Public Inquiry due to existing knowledge about RAAC and ongoing collaboration through the RAAC Cross Sector Working Group. Additionally, it was noted that changes to building legislation would be under the UK Parliament’s jurisdiction, and while Scotland’s Building Standards Act provides enforcement powers, a register of high-risk buildings is not planned due to resource constraints.

In response, Mr. Chowdhry submitted further commentary on 6 October, emphasizing the historical oversight failures surrounding RAAC, which have been known since the 1960s. His response criticizes the lack of comprehensive investigations by safety bodies and calls for the establishment of a national fund to assist homeowners with remediation and fair property valuations. Furthermore, he urges a public inquiry to ensure transparency in council demolition plans and equitable treatment for socio-economically disadvantaged communities. Updating legislation to include a high-risk building registry and detailed property reports is deemed essential to prevent future crises.

Despite reaching out to all MSPs for Clackmannanshire and Aberdeen for support, Mr. Chowdhry has received no written responses from them. However, he received encouragement from Highlands and Islands MSP Edward Mountain, who actively engaged with over 50 homeowners during their protest at the Scottish Parliament on 2 September 2024 (click here). Edward Mountain’s office has confirmed that he has submitted a letter of support for the petition.

Wilson Chairman of the UK RAAC Campaign, said: "Scottish MSPs rarely offer public support for petitions, so we are genuinely moved by Edward Mountain MSP’s empathy," said Wilson Chowdhry. "Even with few RAAC-affected homeowners in his region, he has stepped up to support us. MSP Liam Kerr has also expressed interest in the petition and is receiving updates from the petition committee. I hope more MSPs with affected constituents will follow their lead."

Additionally, Mr. Chowdhry submitted another written response today (click here), urging the Scottish Parliament to allocate a portion of the new £3.4 billion in Treasury funding—announced by UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves—to support homeowners affected by RAAC facing significant financial and safety challenges. This additional funding, which Reeves described as the largest real-terms settlement since devolution, stems from the UK Government's budget and presents a vital opportunity for addressing urgent needs.

The proposed funding could facilitate critical remediation efforts, prevent local councils from acquiring properties at undervalued prices, and ensure that homeowner rights under the Equality Act 2010 are upheld. Furthermore, the proposal advocates for updating Blight Notice procedures to guarantee that councils purchase affected properties at fair market value, thereby safeguarding families from further economic distress.

Homeowners are organizing a protest outside the Scottish Parliament on 13 November from 12 PM to 2 PM ahead of the committee meeting from 9.30am to 10.30am, aiming to influence the Committee’s decisions positively.  Evacuated homeowners from Tillicoultry, along with RAAC-affected residents from Dundee and Deans South, have already confirmed attendance but other affected RAAc regions are expected to join.

Options available to the Committee for action on the petition may include:

  • Requesting additional written information or testimonies from the Scottish Government or other organizations.
  • Inviting the petitioner for further discussion about the petition.
  • Referring the petition to another committee.
  • Recommending actions for the Scottish Government.
  • Calling for a debate on the petition in the Chamber.
  • Closing the petition.

“It’s imperative that MSPs on the Petitions Committee fully grasp the devastating impact the RAAC Homes scandal is having on homeowners across Scotland,” said Wilson Chowdhry. “Many affected individuals are facing severe mental health struggles, some experiencing deep depression and expressing suicidal thoughts, as they face the prospect of losing their homes. They stand to be compensated so little that they risk effective bankruptcy, while councils—backed by an apathetic government—seize the chance to buy up these properties cheaply to develop more lucrative projects. This looming decision is a final thread of hope for thousands of homeowners who fear their entire livelihoods will be stripped away unless the Scottish Government establishes a national fund to protect them.”

Questions Raised Over Aberdeen City Council’s Handling of RAAC-Affected Properties: Delays, Lack of Transparency, and Blight Notice Eligibility

IMAGE: Wilson Chowdhry leads a delegation to 10 Downing Street, delivering a letter and petition to Keir Starmer and Housing Minister Angela Rayner, requesting UK government assistance for the RAAC homes scandal. As of now, they have received no response.

PLEASE JOIN OUR 'UK RAAC CAMPAIGN GROUP' FB PAGE (HERE)

PLEASE SIGN OUR PETITIONS FOR UK GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE) and OFFICIAL SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE)

WATCH FIRST NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL NEWS FEATURE ON RAAC HOUSING CRISES (HERE)

The UK RAAC Campaign Group has raised serious concerns about Aberdeen City Council’s lack of transparency, prolonged delays, and potential legal issues concerning the acquisition of RAAC-affected properties in the Balnagask estate. With Council responses frequently delayed or left incomplete, homeowners are left facing an uncertain future and limited options as the Council fails to provide crucial details around the proposed voluntary acquisition, valuation process, and intended demolition of the estate.

Wilson Chowdhry, Chair of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, has been engaging with the Council since August to obtain clear answers on key questions. Despite Aberdeen City Council representative Stephen Booth’s assurances, responses remain delayed, and essential details continue to be withheld. 

Council Responses Raise Alarming Concerns

In a response dated 8th October, Stephen Booth informed Mr. Chowdhry that the Council had only recently decided to proceed with voluntary acquisitions, explaining that “the decision on the council offering to buy back properties was only made at the recent meeting of full council [August 18th].” However, Mr. Chowdhry’s question regarding how the Council intends to deduct roof repair costs from the “current market value” remains unanswered in practical terms. There is no clear rationale provided for why RAAC-affected homes, which the Council itself built and sold without declaring the use of RAAC as a known unsafe building material, should be valued with such deductions. Mr. Booth’s statement that these deductions reflect “one way to arrive at the current Market Value” raises significant concerns among homeowners, who fear their properties are being unjustly undervalued.

Recently, over 70 homeowners in Aberdeen have united in a decision to withhold cooperation from Aberdeen City Council. The majority have agreed not to engage in the voluntary acquisition process until the Council provides written confirmation that the cost of repairing the RAAC panels will not be deducted from the valuation of their homes. Mr. Chowdhry discussed this issue on That's TV, highlighting the community's concerns and call for transparency.

Additionally, Mr. Chowdhry had requested a breakdown of the types of properties involved—such as one-bedroom, two-bedroom, or larger homes—yet this information remains unavailable. Despite a promise on September 17th that this breakdown would be provided within “the next few days,” residents have yet to receive any information, further fueling distrust in the Council’s engagement process.

Legal Validity of Demolition and Development Decision Questioned

Adding to residents’ anxiety, Mr. Chowdhry has requested confirmation on the legality and validity of the Council’s decision to demolish and redevelop the Balnagask estate without fully secured funding. Mr. Booth indicated that while funding has been identified for initial phases, “officers have been asked to look at a variety of ways to have the site redeveloped for housing,” with no guarantee that additional resources will be available. According to Mr. Chowdhry, this raises concerns about the Council’s accountability and whether the decision to proceed with the demolition and redevelopment is legally sound.

Mr. Chowdhry commented on the apparent legal ambiguity surrounding the Council’s decision:

“The decision to approve demolition and redevelopment of the Balnagask estate without secured funding seems neither legal nor valid to me. The 'best value' approach adopted by Aberdeen City Council appears to avoid paying a fair price to homeowners, driven by budget constraints. Moreover, the proposal to demolish and rebuild, despite the lack of funds for construction, seems like a strategic move to evade the same failures faced by West Lothian Council, who lost their Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO) in 2010 due to serious shortcomings, namely (1) the absence of a formal or approved redevelopment scheme for the Order land and (2) a lack of planning permission, apart from that for the redevelopment of 190 and 192 Deans South.”

A Blight Notice as a Potential Path Forward for Homeowners

Given these prolonged delays, incomplete responses, and lack of transparency, Mr. Chowdhry has requested clarification on whether affected homeowners may be eligible to apply for a Blight Notice under the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997. Should the Council initiate a Compulsory Purchase Order (CPO), a Blight Notice could allow residents an opportunity to petition for early acquisition of their properties, offering some relief amid ongoing devaluation and lack of clear information on redevelopment plans.

Council’s Responsibility to Provide Answers and Accountability

The UK RAAC Campaign Group has sent an email today strongly urging Aberdeen City Council to expedite its response process and provide transparent information on the valuation and acquisition of RAAC-affected homes. Furthermore, the Council is called upon to clarify the legal and financial grounds underpinning its demolition and redevelopment plans, which have already left residents deeply concerned.

Wilson Chowdhry continued:

“These unanswered questions and persistent delays are causing further distress to residents who have already endured enough due to their RAAC-affected homes. Aberdeen City Council must uphold its responsibility to these residents by providing clear, timely answers and ensuring any redevelopment plan is legally and financially viable from the outset.”