Thursday 5 September 2024

Calls for Action at 10 Downing Street Amid Aberdeen Home Undervaluation and Basildon Council Neglect

Willow Chowdhry and Teagan Malone deliver the letters and petition to 10 Downing Street

PLEASE JOIN OUR 'UK RAAC CAMPAIGN GROUP' FB PAGE (HERE)

PLEASE SIGN OUR PETITIONS  FOR UK GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE) and OFFICIAL SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT (CLICK HERE)

WATCH FIRST NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL NEWS FEATURE ON RAAC HOUSING CRISES (HERE)

London, UK – On Wednesday, September 4, 2024, letters and a petition were submitted to 10 Downing Street calling for immediate support for homeowners and tenants across the UK who are affected by the RAAC (Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete) housing crisis. The letters were addressed to Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Housing Minister Angela Rayner, urging the UK Government to establish a national fund to assist councils and housing associations. This initiative aims to prevent unsuspecting homeowners, who were sold properties without knowledge of RAAC issues, from facing homelessness and insurmountable debt due to mistakes made by councils and the Government during the 1960s and 70s construction of ex-council homes, which were later sold off under the Right-to-Buy scheme whose lauded values were failed.

The visit to Number 10 was sparked by Aberdeen City Council's recent decision to demolish and rebuild over 500 homes in the Balnagask area of Torry due to the presence of RAAC. This decision, made during a full council meeting on August 21st, 2024, impacts approximately 366 council-owned homes and 138 privately-owned residences, leaving many homeowners facing severe financial distress. Additionally, the letter highlighted failures by West Lothian Council to provide concrete solutions for homeowners dealing with RAAC, leaving them in a state of uncertainty and limbo. The situation is further compounded by the plight of residents recently evacuated from their homes in Tillicoultry, who are also left without clear resolutions to their RAAC-related issues.

Watch as our petition is submitted to number 10:

The submission was delivered by Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman of the UK RAAC Campaign, along with Angelica Malone, a council tenant from Basildon who is still awaiting a new home after her previous property was confirmed to be RAAC-infested. They were joined by their daughters, Teagan Malone and Willow Chowdhry, and Ben Buckland, a former Scots Guard, who played the bagpipes to emphasize the importance of the event.

An officer within 10 Downing Street receives the letters and petition.

The UK RAAC Campaign is pressing the Government to take swift and decisive action to rectify the longstanding issues caused by RAAC in housing, which have left many families in precarious situations. The petition highlights the need for a national fund that would help cover the costs of repairs, replacements, and the rehousing of affected individuals, ensuring that no homeowner is left behind due to circumstances beyond their control.

VIDEO: A bagpiper led petitioners to the gates of Number 10

Letter to the Prime Minister and Housing Minister:

"Dear Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Housing Minister Angela Rayner,

We write to you on behalf of the thousands of homeowners and tenants across the UK who have been severely impacted by the RAAC housing crisis. It has come to our attention that many residents have been sold homes without knowledge of RAAC issues, resulting in unexpected homelessness and financial burdens. We urge the Government to establish a national fund to support councils and housing associations in managing this crisis effectively.

The legacy of these ex-council homes, initially intended to provide equitable housing and a legacy for future generations, has turned into a nightmare for many due to the failures of previous government schemes. It is imperative that the current Government takes responsibility for these past mistakes and provides the necessary support to prevent further hardship for affected homeowners and tenants.

...We look forward to your urgent attention to this matter and await your response."

VIDEO: As we left 10 Downing Street, the bagpiper played the Scottish National Anthem to underscore the plight of thousands of homeowners in Scotland affected by the Right-to-Buy RAAC scandal. This was also a reminder to the Labour Government of their pledge to 'Deliver for Scotland'.

Concerns Over Valuation Discrepancies and Lack of Council Response in Basildon

Concerns have been raised by affected homeowners in Basildon regarding the valuation of their homes, which have been significantly undervalued by council-appointed surveyors compared to independent assessments. These homeowners have authorized Mr. Chowdhry to represent them in discussions about the discrepancies in valuations. However, multiple emails sent by Mr. Chowdhry and Christine Brady to Basildon Council representatives—including Jonathan Tizzard (Director of Property Services), Emma Perry (Head of Housing), Luke Rapley (Head of Asset Management), Jennifer Hemmingway (Councillor for Housing), and Thomas Burrows (Councillor for Regeneration and Growth)—have gone unanswered.

L-R Wilow Chowdhry (student at Southend Grammar School for Girls), an Officer at 10 Downing Street holding submitted letters, Teagan Malone, Angelica Malone and Ben Buckland.

Council's Rejection of Petition for Public Participation

In a bid to address these issues and seek answers, the UK RAAC Campaign Group attempted to submit an online petition that could permit public participation at a council meeting to discuss the concerns of tenants and homeowners. The text of the petition read:

"In October 2023, Basildon Borough Council informed residents of the Knight Estate that their homes contained dangerous crumbly concrete (RAAC) in the roofs, posing a severe risk of collapse. To mitigate this issue, the Council has offered voluntary agreements to homeowners who are being forced to vacate their properties. However, these offers fall up to £70,000 short of comparable market valuations. The presence of RAAC in the roofs is the direct result of the Council's decision to build these homes using substandard materials before selling them to unsuspecting buyers. Despite the urgency, the Council has continued to ignore email requests seeking approval for designated representatives to speak on behalf of the homeowners. Furthermore, they have failed to provide suitable rehousing options for several Council tenants who remain at risk of their roofs collapsing."

We petition Basildon Council to:

1.Provide fair pre-RAAC-declaration valuations in voluntary agreements for homeowners affected by RAAC who are at risk of losing their homes.

2.Respond promptly to email inquiries from concerned groups and residents, ensuring transparent communication.

3.Allow homeowners the option to authorize designated individuals to communicate on their behalf.

4.Offer a compensation grant of £1000 to private tenants who have been made homeless due to RAAC.

5.Guarantee that all remaining Council tenants are offered suitable rehousing options that meet their needs by the end of September.

Basildon Borough Council rejected the petition, citing that it disclosed personal information and named individuals. Despite adjustments to the petition to remove specific references (we simply removed the name of Knights Estate) and comply with the Council’s guidelines, the revised petition was also rejected with the explanation that it was too similar to a previously submitted petition.

Mr. Chowdhry and Angelica Malone expressed frustration at the Council's actions, describing them as part of a pattern of neglect and obstruction aimed at stifling resident voices and preventing public participation in council meetings. In response, Mr. Chowdhry has written an open letter to the Chief Executive, the Complaints Team, and the Leader of the Council, calling for an opportunity for public participation at a council meeting where the RAAC crisis is discussed and for their petition to be registered and supported by the wider Basildon community.

Council tenant, Angelica Malone, said:

“I am deeply distressed by the ongoing delays in finding us a new home. We’re living in a ghettoised community where council services have been reduced, empty properties are being vandalised, and my young children are now constantly frightened. To make matters worse, we are living under the constant threat of a collapsing roof due to the RAAC issues. I’m calling for a move before the end of September because these delays mean I’ll have to juggle relocating with getting my children to school, something that could have been avoided if the move had happened during the school holidays. It’s incredibly frustrating and unfair to be left in this unsafe and uncertain situation for so long.”

Wilson Chowdhry, Chairman, UK RAAC Campaign Group said:

“The UK Government must act urgently to prevent the impending crisis facing homeowners in Aberdeen who are now at risk of financial destitution due to crippling losses and insurmountable debt. Aberdeen City Council’s decision to offer voluntary agreements at current market values, despite knowing the devastating impact this would have on RAAC homeowners, is unconscionable. Swift government intervention and the creation of a national fund could prevent Basildon homeowners from facing a similar catastrophe. Furthermore, changes to financial policies, including the restoration of first-time buyer status for those who have lost their main residence, would offer vital support to those who would otherwise struggle to buy new homes. This crisis requires immediate attention to safeguard the future of thousands of vulnerable families.”

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Open letter to Basildon Council

To:

  • Kim Bromley-Derry, Chief Executive, Basildon Borough Council
  • Councillor Gavin Callaghan, Leader of Basildon Borough Council
  • The Complaints Team, Basildon Borough Council

Basildon Borough Council
The Basildon Centre
St. Martin's Square
Basildon
Essex
SS14 1DL

Dear Mr. Bromley-Derry, Councillor Callaghan, and Members of the Complaints Team,

I am writing to express my profound disappointment and concern regarding the recent rejection of our petition aimed at addressing the severe and urgent issues surrounding the RAAC crisis affecting residents in Basildon.

Our petition, submitted by Angelica Malone of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, was a crucial step toward ensuring that the voices of tenants and homeowners impacted by dangerous crumbly concrete (RAAC) were heard. The petition sought to address the following key issues:

  1. Provision of fair pre-RAAC-declaration valuations for homeowners.
  2. Prompt and transparent communication from the Council.
  3. Authorization for designated individuals to represent affected homeowners.
  4. Compensation for private tenants made homeless due to RAAC.
  5. Assurance of suitable rehousing options for remaining Council tenants by the end of September.

Unfortunately, the petition was initially rejected on the grounds that it disclosed personal information and named individuals. Despite our efforts to address these concerns by removing specific references to the Knights Estate (which we felt was an overzealous reaction), the revised petition was again rejected, this time due to claims of similarity to a previously submitted petition.

The rejection of our petition is deeply troubling for several reasons:

  1. Neglect of Public Participation: The repeated rejections of our petitions suggest a troubling pattern of obstructing public participation. By denying the opportunity for affected residents to voice their concerns at a Council meeting, the Council is stifling vital discussions that could lead to meaningful resolutions.
  2. Inadequate Communication: The lack of responsiveness to emails and requests from concerned groups and residents undermines the principles of transparency and accountability. Our repeated follow-ups have gone unanswered, contributing to growing frustration and a sense of neglect among the affected community.
  3. Attempted Discrediting: I have meticulously documented a series of requests for a deputation at a full Council meeting, highlighting the Council’s consistent failure to respond until I began daily follow-ups. Complaints have gone unanswered, and there have been divisive attempts to discredit local residents and the UK RAAC Campaign Group. Notably, there have been false accusations of misinformation spread through a WhatsApp group, further damaging trust between the Council and the community.

It is imperative that Basildon Borough Council prioritizes transparency, honesty, and genuine engagement with its residents. The ongoing delays and obstructions must end. The Council must acknowledge the truth of the situation and commit to being more open and responsive to the needs and concerns of its community.

I urge the Council to allow public participation at a forthcoming meeting where the RAAC crisis will be discussed and to register and support our petition. It is time for the Council to demonstrate its commitment to fair and effective governance.

Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter. I look forward to your prompt and constructive response.  Please respond by email.

Sincerely,

Wilson Chowdhry 

Chairman UK RAAC Campaign Group

No comments:

Post a Comment