Saturday 13 April 2024

Relocation Realities: The Misery and Stress of Starting Over Amid Looming RAAC Evacuation



Ericas's home.

We urge you all to continue advocating for a national fund to aid affected homeowners and tenants. Please sign our petition (here)

Please join our UK RAAC Campaign Group Facebook page.

Moving into a new home is often seen as a fresh start, a step towards independence and stability. For many, it's a moment to cherish, a symbol of progress. However, for some, this journey is fraught with unexpected challenges and uncertainties, as Ms. Erica Mitchell has come to realize in her own experience.

Erica Mitchell

In December 2012, Ms. Mitchell made the significant decision to move into her current residence on Pentland Crescent in Torry, leaving behind the comfort of her parents' home in Kemnay, Aberdeenshire. The sense of freedom and autonomy that came with having a place of her own was invigorating. Yet, little did she know that this newfound independence would soon be tested by a series of trials that would shake the very foundation of her security.

The initial years in her new home were marked by the joys of independence and the excitement of decorating the space with the help of her parents. Their support was invaluable as they adorned the walls and furnished the rooms together. However, as time passed, Ms. Mitchell's father's health began to decline, robbing him of the ability to lend a hand as he once did. Her mother, burdened with concern for her husband's well-being and worry over their current situation, found herself torn between caring for her husband and supporting her daughter through their shared challenges.

Over the years, Ms. Mitchell had the opportunity to forge meaningful connections with her neighbors, forming a tight-knit community in the Balnagask area. However, the sense of camaraderie was soon overshadowed by the looming threat of the RAAC (Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete) issue that surfaced in November 2023. Initially met with cautious optimism, the gravity of the situation became apparent with the arrival of subsequent letters in February 2024, detailing the potential safety hazards posed by the materials used in their homes. Ms. Mitchell, explained:

"When we received our second letter in February 2024, informing us that one-on-one meetings would be held with tenants in March regarding RAAC and that our homes are potentially unsafe, I began to dread what would happen next."

The prospect of relocation, presented to them during one-on-one meetings with Housing Support Officers in March, cast a dark shadow over their community. Questions about why these concerns weren't addressed earlier lingered in her mind, echoing the collective sentiment of her neighbors. Ms. Mitchell, added:

"A Housing Support Officer came to see me at the beginning of last month to discuss things in a bit more detail, and I was informed that we might have to move due to the condition of this material. I asked why we were being informed about this now and why nothing came to light before."

As someone who grapples with mental health issues, the added stress and uncertainty have taken a toll on her well-being, leaving her feeling overwhelmed and apprehensive about the future. In an emotional response, Ms. Mitchell, said:

"I have mental health issues, including stress and anxiety, which make it difficult for me to cope. I've been feeling quite upset and tearful over this whole scenario, and the thought of having to pack up all my belongings to move elsewhere is unbearable. I realize that I'm probably not the only person who feels this way, as at the end of the day, we're all in the same boat. I keep thinking that I'll wake up from this nightmare one day and realize it's not happening, but unfortunately, it is."

Despite the challenges she faced, there was a glimmer of hope amidst the chaos. Recent discussions with the council about potential relocation options offered a ray of light in an otherwise uncertain landscape. However, the waiting game continued as she anxiously awaited further updates and guidance. Ms. Mitchell provided further details of her hopeful move.

"I received a phone call from someone at the council on Thursday (11th April) regarding viewing of a property in Kincorth, one of the areas I selected during my one-to-one meeting. I was informed that a housing officer would get in touch with me to arrange this, so I am currently waiting for that."

That hope was recently shattered, however, after Ms. Mitchell explored the offered property and discovered it met none of the criteria she had spent hours explaining to Housing Officers. She shared a Facebook post about her recent experience:


Erica has declined the initial offer, but she's concerned that rejecting another offer could result in her being removed from the Council's waiting list. This loss of priority would leave her facing the looming threat of homelessness.


An image of Erica's email to her housing officers.

As she reflects on this tumultuous chapter in her life, she is reminded of the resilience of the human spirit and the power of community in times of adversity. Though the road ahead may be fraught with challenges, Ms. Mitchell takes comfort in knowing that she is not alone in her struggles. Together, the community will navigate this uncertain terrain, drawing strength from each other as they try to forge a path toward a brighter tomorrow.

Wilson Chowdhry, of the UK RAAC Campaign Group, remarked:

"The situation faced by Erica Mitchell and countless other council tenants is nothing short of dire. 
Erica will bear a multitude of expenses associated with a move, yet she won't receive any compensation for the investments she made in her current property.

"Families with children are gripped with anxiety over potential disruptions to their schooling and the prospect of lengthy journeys to new schools.

"There are valid concerns regarding the affordability of rent in new areas. Torry's rental rates were notably competitive, and families may find themselves financially stretched by the increased costs.

"Compounding matters, delays in utility connections add to the frustration. Families are left wondering how long they'll have to wait for reimbursement of expenses they're entitled to but must pay upfront.

"The financial strain and emotional toll on individuals are significant, with potential repercussions spilling over to local mental health services, already under strain. This untenable situation is entirely the council's responsibility and cannot be ignored."

Following a recent tenants' meeting, where pertinent questions were raised, a response from the housing authority has left many feeling dissatisfied. It's crucial to note that any expenses incurred by tenants may not be reimbursed immediately, adding to local frustration.

Here's a breakdown of some of the queries and responses:

Q1. Post redirection: The housing authority assures that this will be covered under the Disturbance Payment.

Q2. Installation of new equipment: The cost of new aerials, Sky dishes, and internet/broadband setup will also fall under the Disturbance Payment.

Q3. Disconnection of utilities: If required, the housing authority will coordinate disconnection and plumbing services on the day of the move.

Q4. Disruption fee: While a £1500 home loss payment is offered, it may not be provided to all tenants. Those with housing arrears might not be eligible, which has sparked requests for reconsideration. However, tenants are assured support in reducing outstanding balances when moving.

Q5. Taking upgraded items: Tenants have expressed concern about being able to take upgraded items with them without incurring charges. The housing authority advises that all items, including flooring and window coverings, should be removed from the property. Any exceptions should be discussed with the Housing & Support Officer.

Q6. Time limit for moving and rental overlap: Tenants will be supported in moving as quickly as possible. In cases where there's an overlap of tenancies, the housing authority will assist with covering rental charges on the new tenancy.

Q7. Grant access and reimbursement: The housing authority mentions a grant available to tenants, but the criteria for eligibility and the purpose of the grant remain unclear. Tenants are concerned about timely reimbursement if they incur expenses themselves. The authority states that reimbursement will occur once keys are returned, but the process may take a few weeks.

Overall, tenants are left with mixed feelings about the responses received. While some concerns are addressed, others remain unanswered or unclear. Clarity and transparency from housing authorities are essential to alleviate tenant anxieties during what is already a stressful period of transition.

No comments:

Post a Comment